Your Year-End S Corp Payroll Checklist

As the end of the year approaches, S corporation owners have more to think about than closing the books and preparing for tax season. Year-end is a critical time to review payroll, confirm shareholder compensation, reconcile tax payments, and ensure your business meets federal and state compliance requirements.

For S corp owners, payroll requires special attention because shareholders who actively work in the business are generally considered employees. Unlike sole proprietors, they cannot simply take owner draws in place of wages. The IRS requires shareholder-employees to receive reasonable compensation for the services they provide before taking non-wage distributions.

Getting payroll right before December 31 can help prevent tax complications, reduce the risk of penalties, and make filing business and personal tax returns easier.

Whether you manage payroll yourself or work with a payroll provider (like Gusto Solo), use this year-end S corp payroll checklist to ensure you have everything in place before December 31. 

Review your shareholder-employee salary

One of the most important year-end payroll tasks for an S corp owner is confirming that you have paid yourself a reasonable salary.

The IRS requires S corporations to pay shareholder-employees reasonable compensation for the work they perform. This compensation must be processed through payroll and is subject to taxes.

There is no universal salary amount or percentage that automatically satisfies the IRS. Instead, reasonable compensation depends on the services performed, the shareholder's responsibilities, and what similar businesses would pay someone for comparable work.

Consider the following factors when reviewing your salary:

  • Job responsibilities: What duties do you perform, and how much responsibility do you have?

  • Time and effort: How many hours do you spend working in the business?

  • Experience and qualifications: What training, professional experience, or specialized skills do you bring?

  • Industry compensation: What would similar businesses pay someone to perform similar work?

  • Business operations: How much revenue comes from your personal services compared with employees, equipment, or other business assets?

  • Compensation history: How has your salary changed as the business has grown?

Compare your year-to-date wages with the compensation you would reasonably expect to earn in a similar position.

If your salary appears too low, discuss potential adjustments with your CPA or tax professional before the year ends. Waiting until tax season to address insufficient shareholder compensation can create unnecessary complications.

Keep documentation supporting your compensation decision, including job descriptions, comparable salary information, and the reasoning behind your chosen amount.

Make sure shareholder distributions are properly classified

S corp shareholders often receive money from their businesses through a combination of wages and distributions. Although both involve money going to the owner, they receive different tax treatment.

Wages are compensation for services performed and are subject to payroll taxes. Shareholder distributions generally represent the owner's share of the business's earnings and are not subject to payroll taxes. (It’s important to note that distributions cannot simply replace reasonable compensation.)

Review your accounting records and confirm that payments to shareholders have been recorded correctly. Look for:

  • Salary payments processed through payroll

  • Shareholder distributions recorded separately from wages

  • Personal expenses paid by the business

  • Shareholder loans and loan repayments

  • Bonuses or other payments made to shareholder-employees

Pay particular attention to payments that may have been categorized as distributions even though they were compensation for work performed. The IRS can reclassify distributions as wages when shareholder-employees (you!) have not received reasonable compensation.

Also, remember that distributions can have income tax basis implications. Work with your tax professional to review shareholder basis and ensure distributions are properly documented.

Review your final payroll run before December 31

Your final payroll run is a critical part of closing out the year.

If you need to make a salary adjustment, pay a bonus, or include certain taxable benefits in your 2026 wages, timing matters. Wages are reported in the calendar year in which they are paid out, rather than simply when the work was performed. For example, if you intend to include a bonus in 2026 wages but do not pay it until January 2027, it will be reported as 2027 wages.

Before processing your final payroll, review:

  • Total wages paid to each employee

  • Shareholder-employee salary

  • Bonuses and commissions

  • Overtime and other additional compensation

  • Federal income tax withholding

  • Social Security and Medicare withholding

  • State income tax withholding

  • Employer payroll tax obligations

  • Taxable fringe benefits

Check that your payroll records accurately reflect all payments made during the year.

If you use a payroll service, confirm its year-end processing deadlines. Some providers require additional processing time for off-cycle payrolls, bonuses, and benefit adjustments; do not assume that scheduling a payroll on December 31 guarantees it will be treated as 2026 compensation. Confirm the actual payment date and reporting treatment with your provider.

Gusto | Online Payroll Services, HR, and Benefits

Run payroll and benefits with Gusto

Account for shareholder health insurance premiums

Health insurance is another important consideration for S corp shareholders who own more than 2% of the company.

The tax treatment of health insurance premiums paid or reimbursed by an S corporation differs from the treatment of ordinary employee health insurance benefits.

Generally, when the S corp pays or reimburses qualifying health insurance premiums for a more-than-2% shareholder-employee, the premiums must be included in the shareholder's Form W-2 wages in Box 1. However, qualifying premiums are generally not included in Social Security and Medicare wages in Boxes 3 and 5 when the applicable requirements are met. The shareholder may be eligible to claim the self-employed health insurance deduction on their individual income tax return, depending on eligibility requirements.

Before closing payroll, confirm:

  • The total amount of qualifying health insurance premiums paid during 2026

  • Whether the corporation paid the insurance company directly or reimbursed the shareholder

  • Whether reimbursements were properly documented

  • Whether the premiums need to be included in Form W-2 Box 1

  • Whether the shareholder meets the requirements for the individual health insurance deduction

(Be sure not to overlook dental and vision coverage or other potentially qualifying premiums.)

Reconcile payroll taxes and deposits

Throughout the year, your S corp is responsible for withholding and depositing applicable payroll taxes. Year-end is the time to verify that all required payments have been made and that payroll records agree with your tax filings.

Review federal payroll tax obligations, including:

  • Federal income tax withheld from employee wages

  • Employee Social Security taxes

  • Employer Social Security taxes

  • Employee Medicare taxes

  • Employer Medicare taxes

  • Additional Medicare Tax withholding, when applicable

  • Federal unemployment tax (FUTA).

For 2026, the Social Security wage base is $184,500 per employee. Social Security tax is 6.2% for both the employee and employer, up to the applicable wage base.

Medicare tax is 1.45% for both the employee and employer, without the same annual wage cap. Additional Medicare Tax may apply to employee wages exceeding the applicable threshold. Employers must withhold this additional tax when an employee's wages exceed $200,000 during the calendar year (regardless of the employee's filing status).

Compare payroll tax liabilities with the deposits made throughout the year. If you identify an underpayment, overpayment, or reporting discrepancy, work with your payroll provider or tax professional to determine and make the appropriate correction.

(It’s important to remember that payroll tax deposit deadlines depend on your assigned deposit schedule. Making a payment at year-end does not automatically resolve an earlier missed deposit deadline, but the best thing you can do is to correct the missed payment as soon as possible and ensure it is designated for the appropriate Form 941 tax period.)

Verify employee information and W-2 details

Before preparing year-end tax forms, verify that employee information is accurate, because even small errors can cause problems with tax filings, Social Security wage records, and employee tax returns.

Review the following information for every employee, including shareholder-employees:

  • Full legal name

  • Social Security number

  • Current mailing address

  • Total taxable wages

  • Federal income tax withholding

  • Social Security wages and taxes

  • Medicare wages and taxes

  • State wages and withholding

  • Retirement plan contributions

  • Applicable fringe benefits

Also review the W-2 treatment of bonuses, taxable reimbursements, personal use of company vehicles, and other fringe benefits.

If an employee's information is incorrect, address the issue before submitting year-end forms whenever possible.

Review retirement contributions and employee benefits

Year-end is also an opportunity to review retirement plan contributions and other employee benefits.

If your S corp sponsors a 401(k), SIMPLE IRA, or another retirement plan, confirm that payroll records accurately reflect contributions and applicable employer matching amounts.

For shareholder-employees, remember that retirement plan contributions are generally based on eligible W-2 compensation rather than shareholder distributions. Review:

  • Employee elective deferrals

  • Employer matching contributions

  • Employer profit-sharing contributions

  • Annual contribution limits

  • Eligibility requirements

  • Applicable contribution deadlines

  • Payroll reporting requirements

For 2026, the employee elective deferral limit for most 401(k) plans is $24,500, with additional catch-up contribution opportunities for eligible participants.

If you are considering a year-end retirement contribution, contact your plan administrator or tax professional to confirm the applicable deadlines and funding requirements.

Also review other benefits, including health savings accounts (HSAs), dependent care benefits, and taxable fringe benefits. Make sure all benefits are properly classified and reported through payroll when required.

Gusto | Online Payroll Services, HR, and Benefits

Run payroll and benefits with Gusto

Reconcile payroll records with your accounting books

Here’s the bottom line: your payroll system and accounting records should tell the same story.

Before closing the books, compare payroll reports with your general ledger and investigate any differences. Important accounts to review include:

  • Gross wages and salaries

  • Employer payroll tax expenses

  • Employee payroll tax liabilities

  • Federal and state tax withholding liabilities

  • Employee benefit expenses

  • Retirement plan contributions

  • Shareholder compensation

  • Shareholder distributions

Confirm that payroll liabilities have been recorded correctly and that payments to tax agencies agree with the corresponding payroll reports.

Also verify that payroll expenses have been assigned to the appropriate accounts.

For example, employee wages may need to be allocated between administrative expenses, cost of services, or other operating expense categories, depending on the nature of the work.

Reconcile your payroll reports with Forms 941 and applicable state payroll tax returns.

Address outstanding liabilities, uncleared payroll checks, and duplicate transactions before finalizing your year-end financial statements.

A clean reconciliation makes it easier to prepare Form 1120-S and shareholder Schedule K-1s.

Prepare for year-end payroll tax filings

Once payroll information has been reviewed and reconciled, prepare for required year-end federal and state filings.

Common federal payroll forms include:

Form W-2: Wage and Tax Statement 

Employers must provide Form W-2 to employees to report their annual wages and applicable tax withholding.

Form W-3: Transmittal of Wage and Tax Statements 

This form summarizes W-2 information submitted to the Social Security Administration.

Form 941: Employer's Quarterly Federal Tax Return 

Most employers use Form 941 to report wages, federal income tax withholding, and Social Security and Medicare taxes. The fourth-quarter return covers October through December.

Form 940: Employer's Annual Federal Unemployment (FUTA) Tax Return 

This form reports applicable federal unemployment tax obligations.

Forms 1099-NEC and 1099-MISC 

Depending on the type of payments made, your business may also need to issue information returns to independent contractors and other recipients.

Remember that S corp payroll obligations are separate from the corporation's annual income tax filing requirements.

An S corp generally files Form 1120-S and provides Schedule K-1s to its shareholders.

Keep copies of all filed forms, tax payment confirmations, and payroll reports with your business records.

Review state payroll tax requirements

Federal payroll compliance is only part of the process. Your S corp likely has state and local payroll tax obligations, as well.

Depending on your state, you may need to report:

  • State income tax withholding

  • State unemployment insurance contributions

  • State disability insurance contributions

  • Local payroll taxes

  • Quarterly wage reports

  • Annual employee wage statements

For example, California employers generally must file quarterly payroll tax returns and wage reports with the Employment Development Department (EDD).

These include Forms DE 9 and DE 9C, along with applicable payroll tax deposits.

California employers should also review the state's year-end reporting requirements and applicable electronic filing and payment rules.

If your S corp operates in multiple states, review registration, withholding, unemployment insurance, and reporting requirements for each applicable jurisdiction.

Update payroll information for the new year

Before the first payroll of 2027, review your payroll settings and make any necessary updates. Start by confirming employee information, compensation arrangements, and applicable tax withholding elections.

Other items to review include:

  • Updated federal and state withholding information

  • New employee compensation rates

  • Changes to employee benefits

  • Retirement plan contribution elections

  • Applicable minimum wage requirements

  • State unemployment insurance rates

  • Social Security wage base changes

  • Payroll tax deposit schedules

  • Updated business and employee information

If you are an S corp owner, revisit your reasonable compensation arrangement for the upcoming year. Your salary should reflect your responsibilities, business operations, and expected workload, so a salary that was reasonable when the business was smaller may need to be reconsidered as the company grows.

Set a consistent payroll schedule and establish a process for reviewing compensation throughout the year instead of waiting until December.

Wait! I haven’t made my S corp election yet!

The standard deadline for the current tax year is March 15 (so for tax year 2026, that deadline has passed), but if you missed it, you can request late S corp election relief. If you made roughly $70,000 this year as an LLC, you have just weeks left to file your S corp election (that means you need to fill out Form 2553 ASAP) and run a catch-up payroll. Get started with Gusto Solo today and lock in big savings on self-employment taxes. 

Critical payroll deadlines

For most calendar-year employers, several important year-end payroll filing deadlines fall in early 2027.

Because January 31, 2027, falls on a Sunday, the general federal deadlines move to Monday, February 1, 2027.

Deadline

Required action

December 31, 2026

Complete applicable 2026 payroll payments and year-end adjustments

February 1, 2027

Provide 2026 Forms W-2 to employees

February 1, 2027

File Forms W-2 and W-3 with the Social Security Administration

February 1, 2027

File fourth-quarter Form 941

February 1, 2027

File Form 940, when applicable

February 1, 2027

Provide and file Forms 1099-NEC (when required)

Keep in mind that the above are general deadlines. Special rules, filing extensions, deposit-based filing exceptions, and state-specific deadlines may apply in your particular situation. Be sure to confirm obligations using the IRS tax calendar and your state tax agency calendar.

Make year-end payroll part of your annual routine

Year-end payroll should not be an afterthought for S corp owners. It is an opportunity to confirm that shareholder compensation is reasonable, payroll taxes are current, employee benefits are reported correctly, and business records are ready for tax season.

Taking the time to complete these tasks before December 31 can help you avoid unnecessary corrections, reduce compliance risks, and start the new year with more organized financial records.

Most importantly, establish a consistent payroll review process throughout the year. Regularly reviewing compensation, distributions, benefits, and tax payments makes year-end significantly easier and helps keep your S corporation on track. A little preparation before the end of the year can save considerable time, money, and stress when tax season arrives.

Janae Monfort

Janae Monfort | Principal Product Marketing Manager

Janae Monfort is a Principal Product Marketing Manager at Gusto. She has a decade of experience in fintech, spent building and scaling financial tools designed specifically to help business owners manage cash flow, plan for taxes, and unlock financial opportunities. Janae holds a BA in Communication and Media Studies from the University of Southern California, and is based in Seattle.