Gusto
Best all-in-one benefits and payroll platform for small businesses
Gusto is the best all-in-one platform for small and midsize businesses that need benefits administration tightly integrated with full-service payroll. Unlike benefits-only systems that rely on third-party payroll add-ons, Gusto centralizes hiring, payroll, benefits, time tracking, and HR tools in one place. Employee deductions, eligibility, and enrollment changes sync instantly with payroll, reducing errors and administrative work. Its intuitive interface and broad benefits marketplace make it easy to offer competitive benefits without managing multiple systems.
Key Features
Full-service payroll with automated tax filing
Health, dental, and vision benefits administration
Automated benefits deductions synced to payroll
401(k), commuter, and HSA/FSA benefits integration
Seamless open enrollment and change tracking
Employee self-service portal for benefits and pay
Time tracking and PTO management
Onboarding and e-sign document workflows
Compliance alerts and tools
Integrations with accounting, ATS, and time-tracking software
Pros and Cons
Pros
Unified platform reduces errors between benefits and payroll
Transparent pricing with no hidden fees
Large marketplace of benefits providers
Automatic syncing of eligibility and deductions
Excellent employee experience with a single login
Cons
Some advanced HR tools are only available on higher tiers
Not ideal for large enterprises needing global benefits
Custom benefits packages may require broker involvement
Pricing
Simple: {%simple_base_price%}/month + {%simple_per_person_price%}/person/month
Plus: {%plus_base_price%}/month + {%plus_per_person_price%}/person/month
Free trial: Yes — free until first payroll
Free plan: No
Paycom
Best enterprise-grade benefits administration with native payroll integration
Paycom is a fully unified HR and payroll platform designed for companies that want deep benefits administration capabilities, directly integrated with payroll. Its single-database system ensures that benefit elections, deductions, and eligibility changes update instantly across the platform without manual syncing. With powerful self-service tools, open enrollment workflows, and compliance support, Paycom is ideal for mid-sized and enterprise-level organizations that require accuracy, scale, and automation across the entire employee lifecycle.
Key Features
Full-service payroll with automated tax filing
Comprehensive benefits administration, including medical, dental, vision, HSA/FSA
Automated deduction updates that sync instantly to payroll
Self-service enrollment and benefits change management
Compliance tools for ACA reporting
Time and attendance with labor tracking
Applicant tracking and onboarding workflows
Analytics and customizable reporting
Pros and Cons
Pros
Single, unified system for HR, payroll, and benefits
Strong open enrollment and ACA compliance tools
Instant syncing eliminates payroll/benefits errors
Scales well for multi-state or mid-sized organizations
Cons
Pricing requires a custom quote and can be higher than average
Platform may feel complex for very small businesses
Implementation requires dedicated onboarding time
Some businesses may not need its enterprise-level depth
Pricing
Quote-based pricing depending on headcount and modules
Paycom platform bundles payroll and benefits
Add-ons for recruiting, time tracking, and performance tools
Annual contracts are often required
Paychex
Best for small businesses that want hands-on support for payroll and benefits
Paychex is a flexible HR, payroll, and benefits administration platform designed for small and midsize businesses that want expert support alongside automation. The system integrates benefits enrollment, deductions, and eligibility directly with payroll, reducing manual work and compliance risks. With access to benefits advisors, an extensive provider network, and optional HR specialists, Paychex is ideal for employers who want more guidance than self-service tools typically provide.
Key Features
Full-service payroll with automated tax filing
Medical, dental, vision, and retirement benefits administration
Automated benefits deductions synced to payroll
Self-service benefits enrollment and updates
Time and attendance with scheduling tools
HR library and compliance alerts
Optional dedicated payroll specialist
Integrations with accounting and workforce tools
Pros and Cons
Pros
Substantial benefits and payroll integration
Access to benefits advisors and HR specialists
Scales easily as headcount grows
Comprehensive compliance resources
Cons
Pricing requires a custom quote and may be higher for small teams
Interface feels less modern than newer platforms
Add-ons can quickly increase cost
Some HR tools require higher-tier plans
Pricing
Quote-based plans tailored to company size
Add-ons for benefits, time tracking, and HR tools
Payroll and benefits integrations available in higher tiers
Month-to-month or annual contracts depending on plan
Employee Navigator
Best dedicated benefits administration platform with flexible payroll integrations
Employee Navigator is a benefits-focused platform widely used by brokers and employers who need strong benefits administration tools with optional payroll integration. It supports medical, dental, vision, life, disability, and supplemental benefits with automated eligibility tracking and enrollment workflows. The platform integrates with a wide range of payroll providers, making it ideal for organizations that want advanced benefits capabilities without switching payroll systems.
Key Features
Comprehensive medical, dental, vision, and ancillary benefits administration
Automated eligibility, enrollment, and life event tracking
Payroll integrations with major providers
Carrier connections for automated EDI enrollment
Compliance support for ACA, COBRA, and ERISA
Employee self-service portal for benefits and documents
Broker-friendly tools for plan setup and management
Customizable reporting and audit logs
Pros and Cons
Pros
Strong benefits administration for small and midsize employers
Works with many leading payroll systems
Automated carrier feeds reduce manual data entry
Powerful compliance management tools
Cons
Benefits-first platform; limited broader HR features
Interface can feel complex for smaller businesses
Payroll integration quality varies by provider
Implementation may require broker involvement
Pricing
Pricing varies based on broker relationship and employer size
Add-ons for payroll integrations and carrier feeds
Custom quote required for most features
Often bundled through benefits brokers at negotiated rates
APS
Best mid-market HR and benefits suite with fully integrated payroll
APS (Automatic Payroll Systems) is an all-in-one HR, payroll, and benefits platform designed for mid-sized organizations that need a unified system without the complexity of an enterprise HRIS. Its benefits administration module syncs directly with payroll, ensuring accurate deductions, eligibility tracking, and seamless open enrollment. APS is a strong fit for employers who want modern benefits tools, compliance support, and flexible HR features backed by U.S.-based service.
Key Features
Full-service payroll with automated tax filing
Benefits administration for medical, dental, vision, and ancillary plans
Automated deductions that sync instantly to payroll
Open enrollment tools with employee self-service
Time and attendance with scheduling
HR document management and workflows
ACA and compliance reporting tools
Integrations with accounting and ERP systems
Pros and Cons
Pros
Strong mid-market option with integrated HR, payroll, and benefits
Automated syncing reduces payroll and benefits errors
Intuitive interface with modern reporting tools
Dedicated support and implementation assistance
Cons
Not as widely known as national brands like ADP or Paychex
Some advanced HR features may require add-ons
Limited global capabilities
Pricing may be higher for lean teams
Pricing
Quote-based pricing depending on company size and modules
Add-ons for benefits administration, time tracking, and HR
Payroll included in core platform bundle
Support and implementation services included in most packages
Paylocity
Best for modern benefits management with strong payroll connectivity
Paylocity is a modern, cloud-based HR and payroll platform built for mid-sized organizations that need integrated benefits administration with advanced employee experience tools. Its benefits module supports open enrollment, eligibility tracking, and automated deductions that sync directly with payroll. With communication features, surveys, and workforce analytics layered on top, Paylocity is ideal for businesses that want both strong benefits administration and a more engaged, data-driven workplace.
Key Features
Full-service payroll with automated tax filing
Comprehensive benefits administration with open enrollment tools
Automated benefits deductions synced to payroll
HRIS for employee data, documents, and workflows
Time and attendance with scheduling tools
Talent management and learning modules
Employee engagement tools (surveys, community feed)
Robust reporting and analytics
Pros and Cons
Pros
Modern interface with strong employee engagement features
Excellent integration between benefits and payroll
Scalable for multi-state and growing organizations
Wide range of HR modules that can be added as needed
Cons
Pricing is quote-based and may be higher than small-business tools
Feature-rich platform can feel complex to configure
Some modules require additional fees
May be more than very small businesses need
Pricing
Customized quote based on employee count and selected modules
Benefits administration available as part of HR suite or add-on
Payroll included in most bundles
Optional modules for performance, learning, and engagement
TriNet Zenefits
Best modern benefits platform with optional integrated payroll
TriNet Zenefits is a modern HR and benefits platform built to streamline benefits administration for small and midsize businesses. It offers a clean, user-friendly experience for open enrollment, eligibility tracking, and employee self-service, with the option to add Zenefits Payroll or integrate with external payroll providers. This makes it ideal for teams that want sleek benefits tools with flexible payroll options, all within a cohesive HR environment.
Key Features
Benefits administration for medical, dental, vision, and ancillary plans
Automated deduction updates and eligibility tracking
Optional built-in payroll with full-service tax filing
Integrations with third-party payroll providers
Onboarding and digital document management
Time and attendance with scheduling tools
PTO tracking and approval workflows
Employee self-service via web and mobile
Pros and Cons
Pros
Modern, intuitive benefits administration experience
Flexible payroll options: built-in or integrated
Strong onboarding, time tracking, and HR workflows
Ideal for small to midsize businesses
Cons
Payroll is an add-on, increasing total cost
Limited advanced customization for complex benefits setups
Some analytics features available only on higher tiers
Not designed for large enterprise needs
Pricing
Benefits-ready HR base plan: per-employee monthly pricing (custom quote)
Payroll add-on: additional monthly fee per employee
Optional upgrades for time tracking, performance, and compliance
Monthly or annual billing options
Rippling
Best unified HR, IT, and benefits platform with native payroll integration
Rippling is an all-in-one workforce platform that unifies HR, payroll, benefits administration, and even IT management into a single system. Benefits enrollment, eligibility, and deductions sync instantly with Rippling Payroll, eliminating manual updates and reducing compliance risk. With modular add-ons and global capabilities, Rippling is ideal for businesses that want modern benefits tools embedded in a highly automated HR and payroll ecosystem.
Key Features
Integrated benefits administration for medical, dental, vision, and ancillary plans
Automated deductions and eligibility updates synced to payroll
Full-service payroll with automated tax filing
Employee onboarding across apps, devices, and permissions
Time and attendance with scheduling and overtime rules
HRIS for employee data, documents, and workflows
Global workforce tools and support for international benefits
Large integration marketplace and open API
Pros and Cons
Pros
Unified platform eliminates syncing issues between benefits and payroll
Highly automated workflows
Scales for global and fast-growing teams
Modular design allows businesses to add capabilities over time
Cons
Pricing requires custom quotes and can be higher than small-business platforms
Payroll requires using Rippling's HRIS
Implementation can be complex due to breadth of features
Overbuilt for very small teams with basic needs
Pricing
Modular, quote-based pricing
Core HRIS required before adding benefits and payroll
Payroll and benefits priced per employee per month
Optional add-ons for IT, finance, time tracking, and global tools
FAQ
Which is the best software for payroll?
The best payroll software depends on business size and needs. Gusto is one of the strongest all-in-one options for small and midsize companies because payroll, benefits, and HR tools live in a single system. For mid-market and enterprise organizations, Rippling, Paycom, and ADP Workforce Now offer more advanced capabilities and deeper compliance tools.
Does Workday have a benefits module?
Yes. Workday includes a full benefits administration module with open enrollment tools, eligibility tracking, automated deductions, and integrations with carriers. It is designed for large organizations that need to manage complex benefits plans across multiple locations or business units.
Who is ADP's biggest competitor?
ADP's major competitors include Paychex, Rippling, Paycom, and Gusto. Paycom and Rippling compete most directly with ADP for mid-market and enterprise companies, while Gusto is a strong alternative for small and midsize businesses looking for an easier, more modern all-in-one experience.
What software do small businesses use for payroll?
Small businesses commonly use Gusto, QuickBooks Payroll, Paychex Flex, or Square Payroll. Gusto is especially popular because payroll, benefits, and HR tools are integrated into one platform, reducing manual work and making it easy to stay compliant without juggling multiple systems.
Can Workday replace ADP?
Workday can replace ADP for organizations that need a single enterprise system combining HR, payroll, finance, and talent management. However, Workday is typically best suited for larger companies with the budget, internal resources, and complexity that justify an enterprise-level HRIS. Smaller organizations often find ADP or other platforms more cost-effective.