Insubordination is the defiance or refusal to obey authority or follow directives within a hierarchical structure, such as in workplaces, military settings, or educational institutions. Examples include employees ignoring their supervisor’s instructions, soldiers disobeying orders from their commanding officer, or students openly challenging their teacher’s authority. 

It involves deliberately disregarding established rules or commands, usually leading to disciplinary action. However, constructive disagreement or respectful questioning of authority without undermining it does not constitute insubordination. 

Insubordination breaches organizational order and can hinder productivity, cohesion, and effectiveness within the respective environment.

Causes of insubordination

Causes of insubordination at work stem from a variety of issues and include 

  • Dissatisfaction with management
  • Unclear expectations or communication breakdowns
  • Perceived unfair treatment
  • Lack of trust in leadership
  • Personal conflicts
  • Disagreement with policies
  • Low employee morale
  • Job dissatisfaction
  • Lack of consequences

When insubordination occurs in your workplace, it’s important to understand what caused the incident and create a plan to address the issues. 

What is insubordination at work?

Insubordination at work refers to the deliberate refusal to comply with superiors’ instructions or established workplace policies. Examples include outright disobedience, defiance, or simply ignoring requests and tasks given by superiors. 

Insubordination is considered a serious workplace issue because it undermines organizational structure. This can lead to a breakdown of communication and trust and negatively impact a team’s or company’s overall productivity and success. That’s why managers or supervisors must respond with disciplinary action or termination.

How to deal with insubordination

Maintaining a healthy workplace necessitates an effective response to insubordination. To manage it appropriately, document the procedure for legal protection and HR compliance, and for future reference. 

There are several steps a manager can take to address and resolve the issue. 

  1. Evaluate the situation: Assess its context, seriousness, and contributing factors.
  2. Uphold professionalism: Keep the atmosphere calm to foster positivity.
  3. Conduct private discussions promptly: This minimizes tension, prevents rumors, and respects privacy.
  4. Practice active listening: Allow the employee to share their perspective to identify underlying issues.
  5. Clarify expectations: Communicate organizational standards and the consequences of insubordination clearly.
  6. Seek resolutions: Explore potential solutions, such as performance improvement plans.
  7. Use progressive disciplinary measures: Tailor responses to the severity of the behavior, ranging from verbal warnings to termination.
  8. Prevent future incidents: Address systemic issues contributing to insubordination proactively.
  9. Maintain consistency: Treat all cases of insubordination equally to avoid bias.
  10. Engage HR and legal counsel: Seek their guidance, especially in serious misconduct cases.
  11. Monitor workplace culture: Intervene to foster a positive environment.
  12. Provide training and support: Equip employees with conflict resolution skills and ensure compliance with company policies.

Remember to approach each instance of insubordination with respect and fairness. This will set a positive tone and encourage harmony in the workplace. Here are some tips to formulate an effective response:

  • Clearly communicating expectations: Managers should clearly state their expectations and instructions to employees so there is no room for confusion or misunderstanding.
  • Address underlying issues: If an employee’s insubordination stems from personal grievances or conflicts, managers should address these underlying issues and try to resolve them.
  • Document incidents: Managers should record any instances of insubordination, including the date, time, and details of what occurred. This record can be used as evidence if further action is needed.
  • Meet with employees: In some cases, a manager may need to have a one-on-one meeting with the employee to discuss their behavior and find a solution.
  • Ensure disciplinary action is equal to the offense: If an employee’s insubordination continues despite addressing it, managers may need to take disciplinary action, but be sure it’s on par with the seriousness of the employee’s actions. 

Keep reading

Back to top