Which Employees Are Eligible for Unemployment Insurance?

When an employee loses their job, one of the first questions they’ll have is whether they can collect unemployment insurance (UI). As an employer, you may be asked to explain a separation, respond to a claim, or answer an employee’s questions, so it helps to know how eligibility works.

In this article, we’ll cover who is and isn’t eligible, how benefits are calculated and taxed, how employees apply, and what happens if a claim is denied. We’ll also show how much the rules can differ from state to state.

Who is eligible for unemployment insurance?

In general, employees who find themselves unemployed through no fault of their own are eligible for unemployment insurance. This includes:

  • Layoffs

  • Position eliminations

  • Reductions in force

Beyond the reason for being unemployed, there are a few more eligibility requirements:

  • Earnings history. Employees must have earned enough wages, or worked enough hours, during a “base period,” which is usually the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters. Base period thresholds vary a lot from state to state, so it’s important to check in with your own state requirements.

  • Being able to work, available for suitable work, and actively looking for work. For each weekly claim an eligible worker makes, they must be able to show that they meet these three requirements. Many states require about three to five documented work-search activities a week. (If a health issue keeps someone from working, UI is the wrong program—they may be eligible for disability benefits instead.)

  • Being authorized to work in the United States. Eligible workers need valid work authorization (and, generally, a Social Security number) during the base period, when they apply for unemployment benefits, and while they collect benefits.

What makes an employee ineligible for unemployment insurance?

Eligibility rules vary by state, but in most states an employee isn’t eligible for unemployment insurance if they:

  • Were fired for misconduct. Employees fired for willful misconduct, such as theft, harassment, violating a known company policy, or repeated no-shows after warnings, are generally not eligible. Employees let go for poor performance, honest mistakes, or because they weren’t a good fit for the role often still qualify. In many states, the employer has to show the misconduct was willful.

  • Quit without good cause. Employees who quit are typically not eligible. The main exception is “good cause,” meaning a compelling reason that left the employee no reasonable choice but to leave. What counts varies by state, but common examples include:

    • A significant cut in pay or hours

    • A move by the company that substantially lengthens the commute or relocates the job to another state

    • Intolerable or unsafe working conditions, such as discrimination or harassment the employer didn’t address

    • Unpaid wages

    • Domestic violence

    • Relocating with a military spouse

    • A family emergency, such as caring for a seriously ill spouse (some states accept this only if it’s connected to the job)

  • Don’t meet other requirements. Employees may also be ineligible if they:

    • Didn’t earn enough wages or work enough hours during the base period

    • Aren’t able to work or available to work, or aren’t actively looking for work

    • Refuse suitable work

    • Are out of work because of a labor dispute, such as a strike (a few states make exceptions)

    • Were classified as independent contractors rather than employees

    • Provide false information on their claim

    • Receive income, such as severance pay or pension payments, that reduces or delays benefits in some states

Some states don’t deny benefits outright. They may impose a waiting period or reduce benefits instead. And because employers can contest claims, the final decision rests with the state agency.

How do states differ?

Unemployment insurance is a federal-state program, so each state sets its own earnings requirements, benefit amounts, work-search rules, and duration. The differences can be large. A laid-off worker in Washington might collect more than four times the weekly maximum of a worker in Florida, for more than twice as long. The best first step is to check your own state’s rules.

Gusto | Online Payroll Services, HR, and Benefits

Save hours and headaches on HR tasks.

How much do unemployment benefits pay, and for how long?

Most states calculate a laid-off employee’s weekly benefit amount from their wages in the highest-paid quarter of their base period. In many states that works out to roughly one twenty-fifth or twenty-sixth of the highest quarter, up to a state-set maximum. Most states also have a minimum, and maximums range from a few hundred dollars to over $1,000 a week.

Most states pay up to 26 weeks of unemployment benefits, though a number of states pay fewer. Florida, for example, pays up to 12 weeks. Many states also cap total benefits at a share of the employee’s base-period wages, so some workers receive fewer weeks than the maximum. There is often an unpaid waiting week at the start of a claim.

A note on taxes

Unemployment benefits are taxable, which means the IRS treats them as federal income. The state agency then reports total unemployment benefits paid on Form 1099-G. Recipients can choose to have federal tax withheld from their payments. Some states also tax unemployment benefits.

How do employees apply for unemployment insurance?

Employees should file as soon as they become unemployed, since benefits generally can’t be backdated. In most cases, laid off employees should:

  1. Go to their state’s unemployment agency. Employees must file with the state where they worked. Applications can usually be completed online, and often by phone.

  2. Gather their information. Applicants typically need their Social Security number, a government ID, contact and bank details for direct deposit, and their work history for the last 18 months or so, including employer names, addresses, dates, and pay. Non-citizens also need work authorization documents.

  3. Register with the state job service if required. Some states, such as Texas and Florida, require this within a few days of applying.

  4. Certify regularly. Employees must complete a weekly or bi-weekly certification that they were able, available, and looking for work, and report any earnings. Payments only cover weeks that were certified.

The agency will send a determination letter, usually within a few weeks, saying whether the claim was approved.

What happens if a claim is denied?

Denials aren’t always final. Employees can appeal, but the deadlines are short, typically 10 to 30 days from the date the decision was mailed. The deadline is on the denial notice, so employees should act right away. Some states accept late appeals for good cause, but employees shouldn’t count on it.

The process generally looks like this:

  • File a written appeal with the state agency by the deadline, by mail, online, or in person.

  • Keep certifying every week while the appeal is pending. Back payments typically cover only the certified weeks.

  • Attend the hearing, usually by phone or video, before an administrative law judge. Employees can present documents and witnesses.

  • Seek further review if needed. Most states have a second-level review, and decisions can usually be taken to state court.

Employers can appeal too, for example when they believe a claim was approved in error. Respond to every state notice by its deadline, since missing it can mean a decision is made without your input. Keep records of separation reasons, warnings, and policies, because many states require employers to prove misconduct.

Knowing your way around eligibility and what you’re responsible for can help you navigate confidently through unemployment insurance questions. The more informed you are, the more at ease you’ll feel.

Gusto | Online Payroll Services, HR, and Benefits

Save hours and headaches on HR tasks.

FAQs

Who pays for unemployment insurance?

Employers fund the program through federal (FUTA) and state (SUTA) unemployment taxes. In most states, employees don’t pay anything into it. A few states do collect small employee contributions.

Can an employee collect unemployment if they’re still working part-time?

Often, yes. Many states pay partial benefits to workers whose hours or pay were cut, but earnings typically reduce the weekly amount. Rules for how much a worker can earn before benefits stop vary by state.

Will an employee's unemployment claim raise my unemployment tax rate?

Possibly. In most states, your state unemployment (SUTA) tax rate is "experience rated," which means benefits paid to former employees are charged to your account and can raise your rate over time. Responding to claim notices on time and contesting claims that were approved in error can help keep unwarranted charges off your account. Rules vary by state, and some separations are charged differently, so check your state agency's guidance. Gusto's guide to handling an unemployment claim explains how to respond.

What happens if a terminated employee gets unemployment benefits they weren’t entitled to?

Overpayments generally have to be repaid. If the state finds the employee knowingly gave false information, it can add penalties, disqualify them from future benefits, or pursue fraud charges.

Matt Mansfield

Matt Mansfield | Freelance Writer and Tech Editor

Matt Mansfield is a freelance writer and the tech editor at Small Business Trends.