How Do I Pick a Health Insurance Broker?

If you own a small business, you may be among the 21% of small businesses that offer health insurance coverage to employees. And with the median individual premium up 7% year over year, good health insurance brokers can make or break the health care experience for you and your employees.

Yes, you’ll be counting on your broker to find the best plan for your team, but the relationship doesn’t end there. They’ll also help you and your team enroll in the plan you select, aid in the renewal process, and answer any compliance or coverage questions you have. So how do you find the right one?

In this article, we’ll give you a checklist to help you find a health insurance broker who is both qualified and easy to work with.

First things first: do you need a broker to buy group health insurance?

There’s more than one way to buy group health insurance, and the right choice depends on how much guidance you want and how much control you want to keep. There are four options to consider:

  1. Broker. A broker is licensed to sell plans from many carriers, so they can shop the market for you. They’re usually paid through carrier commissions rather than a fee from you. Brokers can be a great fit if you want a human expert to compare options and stay with you year after year.

  2. Agent. Agents/brokers are often referred to interchangeably, but there’s a real difference. A captive or single-carrier agent sells plans from one insurance company. They can know those plans well, but you’ll only see what that carrier offers. Ask any agent upfront whether they’re independent or tied to a single carrier.

  3. PEO (professional employer organization). A PEO is a different model entirely. You become a co-employer with the PEO, and your team joins its group health plan, alongside payroll, HR, and compliance support. This arrangement can unlock plans that might be out of reach for a very small business. The tradeoff is less control over plan design and a bigger commitment than hiring a broker.

  4. Online platform. Online platforms let you compare plans, enroll employees, and manage benefits on your own, often in one place with payroll. They’re a good match if you’re comfortable shopping for coverage yourself and want your benefits and payroll to work together. Some offer access to licensed advisors if you get stuck.

If you want an advocate who knows the market and helps year-round, a broker is usually the strongest starting point.

What to look for in a great health insurance broker

The best brokers do more than hand you a list of plans. They know the market, answer your questions patiently, and stay in your corner long after enrollment. Here’s what to look for.

Licensing and professional qualifications

Start with credentials. Ask what coursework your broker has completed and which professional certifications they hold (some brokers have as many as five).

Next, confirm that your broker is a licensed professional in your state. A licensed broker will be searchable in your state’s department of insurance. Find out the status of their license and see if they’ve ever had any disciplinary action taken against them. You might want to consider someone who’s a member of the National Association of Health Underwriters (NAHU).

Gusto | Online Payroll Services, HR, and Benefits

Run payroll and benefits with Gusto

Small-group experience

Small businesses play by different rules, and a broker with budget-matched experience can find affordable health insurance options and spot cost-saving levers that will make a big difference. You’ll also want to find someone who’s easy to talk to (make sure your team is comfortable with them too) since you’ll be dealing with them directly.

Industry familiarity

Your broker is like a personal plan shopper, so it’s important that they know the industry inside and out while staying neutral on carriers and health insurance companies. On a more granular level, great insurance brokers will work with you to:

  • Evaluate the type of insurance coverage that’s best for your company (and within your budget).

  • Check whether your team’s doctors and hospitals are in your provider network before recommending a plan.

  • Explain deductibles, premiums, and out-of-pocket costs in plain language.

Experience setting up insurance plans

Setting up a group plan is where a broker’s experience really shows. The right one will guide you from your first plan comparison through enrollment, so you launch with confidence and your team gets coverage that works from day one.

They should also be obsessed with keeping you compliant, from tax credits to employee classifications (this is where licensing and ongoing development pay off).

Handles the day-to-day

Health insurance comes with plenty of small but crucial tasks: address changes, new hire enrollments, staying on top of open enrollment periods and renewal deadlines, and everything in between. A great broker handles routine to-dos so you don’t have to.

They’ll also check in regularly to review your plan, so you can adjust coverage (adding vision and dental plans, for example) as your team grows and keep costs in check. And when you’re dealing with insurance companies, health providers, or government agencies, they’ll go to bat for you.

Once you’ve found a broker that checks off all of the above characteristics, you’ll have a partner who handles the details, answers the tough questions, and keeps your team covered year after year. Start by talking to two or three brokers, bring your questions, and choose the one who makes health insurance feel easier. Your team will feel the difference.

Gusto | Online Payroll Services, HR, and Benefits

Run payroll and benefits with Gusto

FAQs

Do I need a broker if I can use healthcare.gov?

Not always, but it depends on what you’re buying. Healthcare.gov is built for individuals and families shopping for their own coverage. If you’re setting up a group plan for your team, a broker can compare small-group plans across carriers, handle enrollment, and support you at renewal, usually at no direct cost to you. If you’re a solo owner with no employees, healthcare.gov may be all you need, and free local help is available if you want a hand.

What’s the difference between a broker and an assister?

A broker is a licensed professional who sells and manages plans, typically paid through carrier commissions. They can help with group plans for your business. An assister (such as a navigator or certified application counselor) provides free, unbiased help understanding and enrolling in marketplace coverage, but doesn’t sell plans or manage your business’s benefits. Brokers are a better match for setting up and maintaining a group plan. Assisters are a good match for individual coverage questions.

When is open enrollment, and does it apply to small businesses?

Small-group plans can generally be purchased year-round, though your plan will have its own annual open enrollment period each year, which your broker or carrier will set with you. Rules can vary by state, so ask your broker what applies to you.

Can I offer an HRA instead of a group health plan?

Yes. A health reimbursement arrangement (HRA) lets you reimburse employees for health costs, including individual plan premiums, instead of buying a group plan. Two types fit small businesses. A Qualified Small Employer Health Reimbursement Arrangement (QSEHRA) is available to employers with fewer than 50 full-time equivalent employees, has annual reimbursement limits set by the IRS, and can’t be offered alongside a group health plan. An Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangement (ICHRA) has no employer size limit and no dollar cap, and lets you set different allowances for different groups of employees. Talk with your broker or a tax advisor about which one fits your team.

Are my employees eligible for Medicaid or financial help if I don’t offer coverage?

Possibly. Eligibility depends on household income, household size, and where they live. Medicaid rules vary by state. Employees who don’t have an offer of coverage through work may qualify for premium tax credits to lower the cost of a marketplace plan, and the enhanced credits that were in place through 2025 have expired, so the amount of help is smaller than it used to be. Households above 400% of the federal poverty level generally no longer qualify for federal premium tax credits, though some states offer their own help. Employees can check what they qualify for at healthcare.gov or with a local assister.

Gusto Editors

Gusto Editors

Gusto Editors, contributing authors on Gusto, provide actionable tips and expert advice on HR and payroll for successful business management.